Search GetCrunchy

Search for categories, articles, and products

Is Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayo Good?

📅 Updated February 2026⏱️ 4 min readNEW

TL;DR

Chosen Foods is one of the cleanest mayonnaise options on the market. It swaps inflammatory seed oils for 100% pure, third-party tested avocado oil and skips the sugar entirely. If you want to upgrade your condiments, this is a top-tier choice.

🔑 Key Findings

1

Verified 100% pure avocado oil by independent UC Davis studies

2

0g of sugar and 0g of carbohydrates per serving

3

Completely free of soybean oil, canola oil, and synthetic preservatives

4

Uses organic, cage-free eggs and organic rosemary extract

The Short Answer

Chosen Foods Avocado Oil Mayo is highly recommended. It replaces the highly processed seed oils found in conventional mayo with 100% pure, third-party tested avocado oil.

With zero added sugar and no synthetic preservatives, it is one of the cleanest condiments you can buy. It delivers the exact same creamy texture as traditional mayo without the inflammatory ingredients. Cleanest Mayonnaise

Why This Matters

Most commercial mayonnaise is a delivery system for cheap seed oils. Brands use soybean or canola oil because they cost pennies on the dollar to produce, but these highly refined oils are linked to chronic inflammation. Oils In Mayonnaise

But replacing seed oils with avocado oil is only helpful if the oil is actually real. A landmark UC Davis study found that 82% of commercial avocado oils are either rancid or secretly cut with cheaper oils. Some bottles labeled "100% pure" were actually entirely soybean oil.

Chosen Foods was one of only two brands verified as 100% pure avocado oil. They trace their supply from grove to bottle and test every batch for purity. When you buy this mayo, you are actually getting the heart-healthy monounsaturated fats you're paying for. Avocado Oil Mayo Healthier

What's Actually In Chosen Foods Mayo

  • Avocado Oil — The first ingredient and the main source of fat. It is verified pure and packed with heart-healthy oleic acid.
  • Organic Whole Eggs & Yolks — Sourced from cage-free chickens to provide the classic creamy texture you expect from real mayo.
  • Organic Distilled White Vinegar & Mustard — These provide the necessary tang and act as natural stabilizers without needing hidden sweeteners.
  • Organic Rosemary Extract — A natural antioxidant used to keep the oil fresh. Conventional brands use calcium disodium EDTA, a synthetic preservative you want to avoid. Is Hellmanns Mayo Clean

What to Look For

Green Flags:

  • 100% pure avocado oil — Look for brands that back up their purity claims with independent testing.
  • Zero added sugar — Real mayonnaise is a savory emulsion that doesn't need sweeteners to taste good.
  • Natural preservatives — Ingredients like rosemary extract or vinegar are safe, traditional ways to extend shelf life.

Red Flags:

  • "Avocado Oil Blend" — This usually means a drop of avocado oil mixed into a vat of cheap soybean or canola oil.
  • Calcium disodium EDTA — A synthetic preservative commonly used in ultra-processed condiments to prevent separation. Is Dukes Mayo Clean
  • Hidden sweeteners — Sugar, high fructose corn syrup, or artificial sweeteners have no place in your sandwich spread.

The Best Options

When it comes to upgrading your condiment fridge, you have a few excellent choices.

BrandProductVerdictWhy
Chosen FoodsClassic MayoVerified pure avocado oil and zero sugar.
Primal KitchenAvocado Oil MayoAnother top-tier clean option with no seed oils. Primal Kitchen Mayo Review
Hellmann's"Avocado Oil" Mayo🚫Misleading label; actually contains soybean and canola oil.

The Bottom Line

1. Ditch the soybean oil. Traditional mayonnaise is highly processed and relies on inflammatory oils. Is Mayo Bad For You

2. Buy Chosen Foods with confidence. Their oil is third-party tested and verified pure by UC Davis food scientists.

3. Stock up at Costco. This mayo is a healthy kitchen staple, and buying the larger jars will save you a significant amount of money over time.

FAQ

Does Chosen Foods mayo taste like avocado?

No, it tastes like classic mayonnaise. Avocado oil has a completely neutral flavor profile, making it the perfect clean base for a traditional creamy mayo taste.

Is it better than Primal Kitchen?

They are tied for the cleanest mayonnaise. Both brands use pure avocado oil and zero sugar. Chosen Foods tends to be slightly creamier, while Primal Kitchen has a more pronounced vinegar tang. Primal Kitchen Mayo Review

Does it need to be refrigerated?

You must refrigerate it after opening. Because it lacks synthetic preservatives like calcium disodium EDTA, it will spoil if left in the pantry. Keep it away from the back wall of the fridge, as real avocado oil mayo can separate if it freezes.


References (12)
  1. 1. businesswire.com
  2. 2. iherb.com
  3. 3. thrivewholefoodsgh.com
  4. 4. chosenfoods.com
  5. 5. food4less.com
  6. 6. bakersplus.com
  7. 7. therootcellarpei.com
  8. 8. heinens.com
  9. 9. fooducate.com
  10. 10. ucdavis.edu
  11. 11. chosenfoods.com
  12. 12. newfoodmagazine.com

🛒 Product Recommendations

Classic Avocado Oil Mayo

Chosen Foods

A gold-standard clean mayo with third-party verified pure avocado oil.

Recommended
Avocado Oil Mayo

Primal Kitchen

Another excellent clean option that uses no sugar or seed oils.

Recommended
🚫
Real Mayonnaise

Hellmann's

Loaded with inflammatory soybean oil and calcium disodium EDTA.

Avoid

Roasted Garlic Avocado Oil Mayo

Chosen Foods

A flavorful variation that maintains the brand's high standards. It uses 100% pure avocado oil and real roasted garlic puree without any added sugar or synthetic preservatives.

Recommended
Garlic Aioli Mayo

Primal Kitchen

An excellent clean alternative that uses pure avocado oil and organic cage-free eggs. It is flavored with organic lemon and garlic oils rather than artificial flavors and contains no sugar.

Recommended

Avocado Oil Mayo

Thrive Market

A verified clean option for online shoppers. It uses 100% avocado oil as the only fat source (no filler oils) and is free from sugar, soy, and canola.

Recommended

Sugar Free Avocado Oil Mayo

Sir Kensington's

One of the few mainstream options that is explicitly Keto and Paleo Certified. It uses 100% avocado oil and organic free-range egg yolks, completely omitting the cane sugar found in their classic line.

Recommended
Chipotle Avocado Oil Mayo

Chosen Foods

Ideal for those wanting heat without the junk. It relies on real chipotle peppers and smoked paprika for flavor, using pure avocado oil as the base instead of the cheap soybean oil found in most spicy sauces.

Recommended

Vegan Mayo Spread & Dressing

Trader Joe's

A rare vegan find that actually uses quality oil. Unlike most plant-based mayos that rely on canola or sunflower oil, this uses avocado oil as the primary fat, emulsified with a chickpea broth.

Recommended
Chipotle Lime Mayo

Primal Kitchen

Another top-tier flavored option using 100% avocado oil. It contains zero sugar and gets its flavor from organic chipotle powder and lime oil, avoiding the 'natural flavors' loophole.

Recommended
👌

Organic Mayonnaise

Tessemae's

A decent shelf-stable option if avocado oil isn't available. It uses high-oleic sunflower oil (which is better than standard soy/canola) and is completely sugar-free and gum-free.

Acceptable
👌

Avocado Oil Vegenaise

Follow Your Heart

A better-than-average vegan option, but not perfect. While it highlights avocado oil, it is a blend that also contains high-oleic safflower oil and brown rice syrup.

Acceptable
👌

Mayo Made With Coconut Oil

Wildly Organic (Wilderness Family Naturals)

A unique blend of organic coconut, olive, and sesame oils. It avoids inflammatory seed oils entirely but does contain evaporated cane juice, making it slightly less clean than the sugar-free options.

Acceptable
🚫

Reduced Fat Mayonnaise with Olive Oil

Kraft

A classic example of 'health-washing' on the label. Despite the name, the primary ingredients are water, modified corn starch, and soybean oil, with calcium disodium EDTA used as a preservative.

Avoid
🚫

Avocado Oil Mayo

BetterBody Foods

Do not be fooled by the front label. While it uses avocado oil, it ruins the clean profile by adding calcium disodium EDTA, a synthetic preservative that premium brands specifically avoid.

Avoid
🚫

Real Mayonnaise

Kirkland Signature (Costco)

A budget bulk buy that compromises on quality. It relies on soybean or canola oil (depending on the batch) and contains calcium disodium EDTA to preserve shelf life.

Avoid
⚠️

Organic Mayonnaise with Olive Oil

Spectrum

Misleading labeling obscures the truth. The primary ingredient is actually organic soy oil, not olive oil, meaning you are still consuming the high-omega-6 seed oils you likely wanted to avoid.

Use Caution
🚫
Real Mayonnaise

Blue Plate

A Southern staple that fails modern health standards. It is made primarily from soybean oil and contains added sugar and calcium disodium EDTA.

Avoid
⚠️

Organic Mayonnaise

Simple Truth (Kroger)

Proof that 'organic' doesn't always mean healthy. The first ingredient is organic soybean oil, which is still an inflammatory high-omega-6 fat, even if grown without pesticides.

Use Caution
⚠️

Organic Mayonnaise

O Organics (Safeway/Albertsons)

Another store brand that misses the mark. It is almost identical to other generic organic mayos, relying on organic soybean oil and sugar rather than higher quality fruit oils.

Use Caution
🚫

Real Mayonnaise

Great Value (Walmart)

An ultra-processed budget option. It is composed of soybean oil, sugar, and calcium disodium EDTA, lacking the nutrient density of avocado oil-based competitors.

Avoid
🚫

Light Mayonnaise

Duke's

To lower the calorie count, this product replaces healthy fats with fillers. It adds modified food starch, potassium sorbate, and natural flavors to a soybean oil base.

Avoid
🚫

Canola Cholesterol Free Mayonnaise

Hellmann's

Marketing 'cholesterol free' masks a poor ingredient list. It uses highly processed canola oil, modified food starch, sugar, and synthetic preservatives like calcium disodium EDTA.

Avoid
⚠️

Organic Mayonnaise

Sprouts Farmers Market

Despite the health-focused retailer, this house brand is standard fare. It relies on organic soybean oil as the base fat, offering no advantage over standard organic mayos.

Use Caution
🚫

Japanese Mayonnaise

Kewpie

While culinarily popular for its umami flavor, it is not a health product. It is made with soybean oil and contains Monosodium Glutamate (MSG), which many health-conscious consumers try to avoid.

Avoid

💡 We don't accept payment for recommendations. Some links may be affiliate links.

📖 Related Research

🍅

Explore more

More about Condiments & Sauces

Hidden sugar and seed oils everywhere