The Short Answer
Nutella is not a breakfast food. It is a dessert spread that is nutritionally closer to a candy bar than a nut butter.
The product is 58% sugar. A standard 2-tablespoon serving delivers 21 grams of sugar and 200 calories, with only 2 grams of protein. In 2012, the parent company, Ferrero, paid over $3 million to settle a class-action lawsuit for misleading parents into thinking it was a part of a nutritious breakfast.
Why This Matters
It’s mostly frosting.
If you look at the ingredient list, sugar is first. Palm oil is second. Hazelnuts—the ingredient the product is named after—come in third, making up only about 13% of the jar. For comparison, a real nut butter is usually 90-100% nuts.
Palm oil concerns.
Nutella relies heavily on palm oil for its spreadable texture. While Ferrero has made strides in sustainable sourcing (RSPO certified), refined palm oil is high in saturated fat and has been linked to potential processing contaminants (like GE and 3-MCPD) when heated to high temperatures during refining.
The "Health Halo" effect.
Because it highlights hazelnuts and milk, consumers often categorize it alongside peanut butter. This is dangerous for blood sugar management. A serving of peanut butter has ~1-2g of sugar; Nutella has 21g.
What's Actually In Nutella
Nutella's recipe is simple, but not in a good way.
- Sugar — The primary ingredient. You are eating more sugar than anything else. Is Sugar Toxic
- Palm Oil — A cheap, semi-solid fat used to give the spread its creamy texture and shelf stability. High in saturated fat. Palm Oil In Peanut Butter
- Hazelnuts (13%) — A surprisingly small portion of the recipe. Real hazelnut butter should be mostly hazelnuts.
- Skim Milk — Powdered milk adds creaminess but also contains oxidized cholesterol from the spray-drying process.
- Cocoa — Provides the chocolate flavor but is far down the list compared to sugar and oil.
- Lecithin — Usually soy-derived, used as an emulsifier to keep the oil and sugar mixed.
- Vanillin — An artificial flavor. It is not real vanilla extract. It's a synthetic compound often derived from wood pulp or petrochemicals.
What to Look For
When buying chocolate hazelnut spreads, ignore the front label and flip to the back.
Green Flags:
- Hazelnuts are #1 — The first ingredient should be nuts, not sugar.
- "Cocoa Butter" or "Coconut Oil" — Better fat sources than palm oil.
- Under 10g Sugar — A treat shouldn't wreck your blood sugar for the day.
- Real Vanilla — Look for "Vanilla Extract" or "Vanilla Bean," not "Vanillin."
Red Flags:
- Sugar is #1 — This is candy, plain and simple.
- Palm Oil — Often indicates a highly processed product.
- "Flavoring" — Code for artificial chemicals.
- Low Protein — Anything with less than 3-4g of protein is likely just sugar and fat.
The Best Options
You don't have to give up chocolate hazelnut spreads. You just need to buy the ones that are actually food.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rigoni di Asiago | Nocciolata (Organic) | ✅ | Palm-oil free, organic ingredients, tastes identical to Nutella. |
| Nutiva | Hazelnut Cacao Spread | ✅ | 40% less sugar, fair-trade palm oil, chia/flax added. |
| Justin's | Chocolate Hazelnut Butter | ⚠️ | Clean ingredients, but texture is gritty and dry compared to others. |
| Ferrero | Nutella | 🚫 | 58% sugar, artificial flavors, refined palm oil. |
The Bottom Line
1. Treat it like cake frosting. If you wouldn't eat a spoonful of frosting for breakfast, don't eat Nutella.
2. Switch to Nocciolata. If you crave that specific creamy texture, Rigoni di Asiago's Nocciolata is the closest cleaner swap.
3. Check the first ingredient. If it says "Sugar" first, put it back. Good spreads list "Hazelnuts" first.
FAQ
Is Nutella healthy for kids?
No. A 2-tablespoon serving has 21 grams of sugar, which is nearly the entire daily recommended limit for a child. It promotes blood sugar spikes and energy crashes.
Does Nutella use real chocolate?
Barely. It uses a small amount of fat-reduced cocoa powder, but the primary ingredients are sugar and oil. It legally cannot be labeled as "chocolate cream" in Italy because the cocoa content is too low.
Why is palm oil in Nutella bad?
Palm oil is high in saturated fat and, when refined at high temperatures, can contain process contaminants. While Ferrero claims their processing is safe, the environmental impact of palm oil production (deforestation) remains a major global concern. Palm Oil In Peanut Butter
References (27)
- 1. snopes.com
- 2. hcplive.com
- 3. wikipedia.org
- 4. healthline.com
- 5. manatt.com
- 6. skinnypancake.com
- 7. lucangeli.co
- 8. yukitchen.com
- 9. meghantelpner.com
- 10. mashed.com
- 11. thedailymeal.com
- 12. medium.com
- 13. theworld.org
- 14. wixsite.com
- 15. topclassactions.com
- 16. wellnessmama.com
- 17. bodi.com
- 18. prescouter.com
- 19. jacopomauro.com
- 20. mashable.com
- 21. nutella.com
- 22. mentalfloss.com
- 23. oliveoiltimes.com
- 24. reddit.com
- 25. quora.com
- 26. eatwiser.com.au
- 27. ferrerofoodservice.com