Search GetCrunchy

Search for categories, articles, and products

Is Farmer's Dog Good?

šŸ“… Updated February 2026ā±ļø 4 min readNEW
⚔

TL;DR

The verdict depends on your dog's health and your budget. The Farmer's Dog is a massive ingredient upgrade formulated by actual veterinary nutritionists, but it is incredibly expensive and high in fat. Owners of large breeds could pay over $18 a day, and dogs prone to pancreatitis should avoid the richer recipes entirely.

šŸ”‘ Key Findings

1

The Farmer's Dog employs three full-time Board-Certified Veterinary Nutritionists and meets WSAVA guidelines.

2

Feeding a large 60+ lb dog can cost anywhere from $9.00 to $18.98 per day.

3

Some recipes contain up to 27% fat on a dry matter basis, which is significantly higher than the 12-15% found in average kibble.

4

The formulas are grain-free and rely on legumes and potatoes, which have been investigated for potential links to canine heart disease.

The Short Answer

The Farmer's Dog is a massive upgrade over highly processed kibble. It is expertly formulated by veterinary nutritionists and uses human-grade meat and vegetables.

However, the verdict depends on your dog's health and your budget. The recipes are grain-free, incredibly high in fat, and can cost over $18 a day for large breeds. Fresh Dog Food Vs Kibble

Why This Matters

The fresh dog food market is exploding, but most boutique brands lack actual scientific backing. They rely on slick marketing rather than clinical veterinary science. Healthiest Dog Food

The Farmer's Dog is a rare exception because it employs three full-time board-certified veterinary nutritionists. They are a WSAVA Diamond Partner and recently completed rigorous long-term feeding trials at Cornell University. What Dog Food Do Vets Recommend

But premium quality comes at a steep price. Feeding a large dog can cost up to $18 a day. That translates to over $500 a month just for dog food.

You also have to navigate the grain-free debate. The FDA has investigated diets heavy in legumes for potential links to canine heart disease. Because The Farmer's Dog uses chickpeas and lentils, some veterinarians recommend caution. Does Grain Free Cause Heart Disease

What's Actually In The Farmer's Dog

  • Human-Grade Meat — They use whole muscle and organ meat instead of rendered powders, ensuring your dog gets highly digestible protein. Is Meat Meal Bad
  • Fresh Vegetables — Broccoli, carrots, and green beans are gently cooked in, providing natural antioxidants and vital dietary fiber.
  • Legumes & Tubers — Chickpeas, lentils, and sweet potatoes act as carbohydrate sources, which have been scrutinized for potential links to canine heart disease. Is Pea Protein In Dog Food Bad
  • Salmon Oil — Added for a bioavailable source of Omega-3 fatty acids, which naturally supports joint health and a shiny coat. Is Fish Oil Good For Dogs

What to Look For

Green Flags:

  • WSAVA Alignment — They actually meet global veterinary guidelines. Having full-time board-certified nutritionists is the gold standard for pet food safety.
  • Human-Grade Facilities — The food is cooked in USDA-inspected kitchens. This avoids the frequent contamination issues that plague traditional pet food plants. What Dog Foods Have Been Recalled

Red Flags:

  • High Fat Content — Some recipes contain up to 27% fat on a dry matter basis. This richness can trigger severe GI distress or pancreatitis in sensitive dogs.
  • Grain-Free Formulas — The lack of traditional grains concerns some vets. If your dog is prone to cardiac issues, you need to discuss legume-heavy diets with your vet. Is Grain Free Dog Food Safe

The Best Options

If you decide to try the subscription, choosing the right recipe is critical for your dog's digestion. Here is how their main proteins stack up. Farmers Dog Vs Ollie

BrandProductVerdictWhy
The Farmer's DogTurkey Recipeāœ…The lowest fat option makes it the safest bet for sensitive stomachs.
The Farmer's DogPork Recipeāœ…An excellent novel protein that helps dogs with common chicken or beef allergies.
The Farmer's DogBeef Recipeāš ļøThe highest fat content can cause diarrhea or trigger pancreatitis in prone dogs.

The Bottom Line

1. Talk to your vet first. You need to ensure a grain-free, high-fat diet is appropriate for your specific breed.

2. Transition incredibly slowly. Moving from dry kibble to rich, fresh food will cause explosive diarrhea if you switch faster than the recommended 10 days.

3. Use it as a topper. If the cost is too high, mixing a small amount with a high-quality kibble provides fresh nutrients on a budget. Is Kibble Bad For Dogs

FAQ

Does The Farmer's Dog cause pancreatitis?

There is no clinical proof that the food directly causes pancreatitis in healthy dogs. However, the fat content is significantly higher than average kibble. If your dog has a history of pancreatic or severe GI issues, you should absolutely avoid this food.

Is The Farmer's Dog raw?

No, the food is gently cooked to 165 degrees. This eliminates dangerous pathogens like Salmonella while preserving more nutrients than the extreme heat used to make kibble. Is Raw Dog Food Safe

Is The Farmer's Dog WSAVA compliant?

Yes, they meet or exceed global veterinary guidelines. Unlike many boutique brands, they employ full-time veterinary nutritionists, manufacture in FDA-compliant facilities, and run comprehensive feeding trials. What Dog Food Do Vets Recommend


References (13)
  1. 1. thequalityedit.com
  2. 2. thefarmersdog.com
  3. 3. thefarmersdog.com
  4. 4. thefarmersdog.com
  5. 5. thefarmersdog.com
  6. 6. forbes.com
  7. 7. thefarmersdog.com
  8. 8. deliveryrank.com
  9. 9. thefarmersdog.com
  10. 10. youtube.com
  11. 11. wsava.org
  12. 12. petful.com
  13. 13. reviewed.com

šŸ›’ Product Recommendations

šŸ‘Œ
The Farmer's Dog Fresh Food

The Farmer's Dog

High-quality, human-grade food, but monitor dogs prone to GI issues due to the rich fat content.

Acceptable
āœ…

Beef Mash

Nom Nom

Excellent for owners who want rigorous safety; ingredients are cooked individually to preserve nutrients before mixing. The formula is developed by Dr. Justin Shmalberg, a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, and includes a specific nutrient mix to ensure WSAVA compliance.

Recommended
āœ…

Pancreatic Support Beef

Raised Right

The safest fresh option for dogs prone to pancreatitis, with a lab-tested fat content of approx. 6% (significantly lower than The Farmer's Dog). Each batch is tested for pathogens like E. coli and Salmonella before shipping, with results posted publicly on their website.

Recommended
āœ…

Venison Patty

We Feed Raw

Ideal for raw feeding without the pathogen risk, as they use High-Pressure Processing (HPP) to neutralize bacteria like Listeria. The venison is a novel protein suitable for allergic dogs, and the company offers a bulk option that can be cheaper than subscription trays.

Recommended
āœ…

Food for Dogs (Beef Recipe)

Sundays

A unique air-dried texture that bridges the gap between kibble convenience and fresh food nutrition. It contains over 90% meat and organs with no synthetic binders, and unlike frozen fresh food, it requires no refrigeration or thawing.

Recommended
āœ…

UnKibble Beef + Barley

Spot & Tango

Uses a 'Fresh Dry' process to create a shelf-stable product with human-grade ingredients at a lower price point than frozen subscriptions. It avoids the extrusion process of traditional kibble, preserving more natural nutrients without the mess of wet food.

Recommended
āœ…

Harvest Chicken Gently Cooked

Open Farm

Offers complete supply chain transparency; you can scan the lot code on the bag to see the origin of every ingredient. The chicken is Global Animal Partnership (GAP) Step 2 certified, ensuring higher welfare standards than standard commercial poultry.

Recommended
āœ…

Fish & Sweet Potato

JustFoodForDogs

One of the few fresh diets supported by extensive clinical research and sold directly in veterinary clinics. The fish recipe is low in fat and easily digestible, making it a frequent recommendation for dogs with sensitive stomachs or IBD.

Recommended
šŸ‘Œ

Sensitive Skin & Stomach (Salmon)

Purina Pro Plan

A science-backed, WSAVA-compliant kibble that serves as a reliable budget alternative or mixer. It is fortified with live probiotics for digestive health and uses hydrolyzed soy and salmon to minimize allergic reactions.

Acceptable
āœ…

Dehydrated Grain-Free Beef

The Honest Kitchen

The original 'human-grade' pet food; this dehydrated powder rehydrates into a fresh-like stew. It allows for easy storage and travel while providing whole-food nutrition without the extreme processing of kibble.

Recommended
āœ…

Texas Beef Stew

A Pup Above

Uses a sous-vide cooking method (slow-cooked in vacuum-sealed bags) which retains more moisture and flavor than boiling. The protein content is notably higher than many competitors, with the beef recipe boasting 53% protein on a dry matter basis.

Recommended
āœ…

Fresh Turkey Recipe

Ollie

Employs a team that includes vet nutritionists to ensure recipes meet AAFCO standards for all life stages. Their portioning technology is highly precise, helping owners of overweight dogs manage calories more effectively than eyeballing scoops.

Recommended
āœ…

Air-Dried Lamb

Ziwi Peak

The gold standard for air-dried toppers, sourced entirely from New Zealand grass-fed pastures. It contains 96% meat, organs, and bone, including green-lipped mussel which provides natural glucosamine for joint support.

Recommended
šŸ‘Œ

Canine Health Miracle Premix

Dr. Harvey's

A 'just add meat' base mix that gives owners total control over the protein source and quality. It consists of freeze-dried organic vegetables and herbs, eliminating the need to balance calcium and phosphorus yourself.

Acceptable
āœ…

Ohana Puppy Formula

Annamaet

A family-owned boutique brand that actually conducts rigorous testing and is formulated by a nutrition expert. It uses algae-derived DHA for brain development and avoids the common pitfalls of other boutique brands by sticking to science-based formulation.

Recommended
🚫

Ground Beef & Chicken Recipes

Viva Raw

Has faced multiple serious recalls in 2024 and 2025 for Salmonella and Listeria contamination across several protein lines. The frequency of these safety breaches makes it a risky choice despite the popularity of their marketing.

Avoid
āš ļø

Hi-Pro Plus

Victor

Historically a favorite, but the brand suffered a massive Salmonella recall in late 2023 that was linked to human illnesses. While they have implemented new safety protocols, the scale of the breach warrants caution until a longer safety track record is established.

Use Caution
🚫

Puppy Mix

Blue Ridge Beef

A serial offender with repeated recalls in 2023, 2024, and 2025 due to Salmonella and Listeria findings. The consistent inability to control pathogens in their raw products poses a significant health risk to both pets and owners.

Avoid
🚫

Complete Nutrition

Ol' Roy

Uses BHA and BHT (synthetic preservatives linked to cancer risks in some studies) and relies heavily on generic 'meat and bone meal'. It also contains Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 2 artificial dyes which add zero nutritional value.

Avoid
🚫

Bistro Meals

Kibbles 'n Bits

Contains propylene glycol (a moisture preserver) and corn syrup as major ingredients to create a semi-moist texture. The protein sources are primarily plant-based fillers like soy and corn rather than quality animal meat.

Avoid
āš ļø

Select Beef & Vegetables Roll

Freshpet

While fresh, this specific line often uses Carrageenan as a thickener, an additive linked to gastrointestinal inflammation. It is also pasteurized rather than gently cooked, and has lower protein density compared to premium subscription brands.

Use Caution
āš ļø

High Prairie Grain-Free

Taste of the Wild

Frequently cited in the FDA's investigation into Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM) due to its heavy reliance on peas and legumes. It is manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, a facility with a history of large-scale recall events.

Use Caution
āš ļø

Wilderness Chicken Recipe

Blue Buffalo

Heavily marketed as 'wolf-diet' compliant but relies on pea protein and other legumes that are under scrutiny for heart health risks. The brand has also settled class-action lawsuits regarding misleading labeling claims in the past.

Use Caution
🚫
Adult Complete Nutrition

Pedigree

Issued a recall in 2024 for potential loose metal pieces in bags. The formula is dominated by corn and meat by-product meal, providing poor digestibility compared to modern standards.

Avoid
🚫

Originals with Beef

Beneful

Contains added sugar and multiple artificial colors (Red 40, Yellow 5, Yellow 6) to make the food look appealing to humans. The 'real beef' claim is diluted by a high volume of corn and wheat fillers.

Avoid
🚫

Filets in Gravy

Cesar

Sold as a premium 'gourmet' option but is primarily water, meat by-products, and wheat flour. It has a high salt content relative to its nutritional value, which can be problematic for older small dogs with heart issues.

Avoid
āš ļø

Kangaroo Formula

Zignature

A boutique brand that heavily utilizes legumes (lentils, peas, chickpeas) as a grain substitute, which places it high on the list of diets associated with DCM cases. They historically have not employed full-time veterinary nutritionists for formulation.

Use Caution
🚫

Wholesomes

Sportmix

Associated with a deadly Aflatoxin recall in 2021 that resulted in the deaths of over 100 dogs. This history highlights a catastrophic failure in testing corn ingredients for mold toxins.

Avoid
āš ļø

Superfood Complete

Badlands Ranch

While the ingredients are acceptable (air-dried beef), the price is exorbitant (~$60+/bag) due to celebrity marketing rather than superior science. The 'fear-based' advertising tactics regarding 'toxic kibble' are misleading to consumers.

Use Caution

šŸ’” We don't accept payment for recommendations. Some links may be affiliate links.

šŸ“– Related Research

🐾

Explore more

More about Pet Products

What's really in their bowl